.
Feedback

Letter to the Editor: Peninsula Hospital Closing Leaves Big Rift

Writer says residents need to work together to think of ways to mitigate the situation.

This letter was submitted by Elisa Hinken.

Peninsula Hospital in Far Rockaway was closed on April 9. The surge of patients across the border into Nassau County has been felt.  

My daughter, a firemedic with the (volunteer) reports that increased emergency room wait time has been experienced at South Nassau Communities Hospital in Oceanside. Others have reported the same thing at Franklin General in Valley Stream. Meanwhile, St. John’s Episcopal Hospital in Far Rockaway, which also serves the Five Towns in Nassau County, has experienced extensive waiting times for emergency care and is frequently on ambulance diversion.

New York State Department of Health held a public forum, as mandated by PHL 2801-g, on Thursday, May 10, from 3 to 7 p.m. at the Knights of Columbus Hall, 333 Beach 90 Street. Dr. Shah, Commissioner of Health attended, as did Richard Cook, James Clancy and Celeste Johnson, assistant commissioners. Over 400 residents of the Rockaway peninsula, Five Towns and nearby communities attended. Testimonies were taken and recorded. Written comments were also submitted. 

A wide range of topics were presented to the panel, who were there solely to listen to the community as to the impact of a closed hospital has. Within 60 days the commissioner must publish the plan to ameliorate the situation and impact on the entire Rockaways/Five Towns community. We know that St. John’s Episcopal Hospital has plans to expand services in order to lessen the impact, but there is no replacement for a second emergency room on the peninsula. Already St. John’s Episcopal Hospital has been on ambulance diversion numerous times, pushing patients further into the Nassau County areas. South Nassau Communities Hospital, Franklin General and Winthrop are also feeling this “push back” effect. A level I trauma Emergency Room at Jamaica Hospital cannot be considered as an alternative because of the tremendously heavy traffic flow on Rockaway Turnpike and the Van Wyck Expressway.

We ask for support from the Five Towns community to share their ideas and concerns on the Rockaway Health Care Alliance page on Facebook. Before a terrible tragedy occurs, emergency hospital access should be the highest priority for the community.

You can read the law concerning the hospital closure law here:  https://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=447252841967314 — it is on a Facebook page run by a group called the Rockaway Health Care Alliance.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Five Towns Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Bojames May 17, 2013 at 08:15 pm
All above by the original writer notwithstanding it is morally reprehensible that people who did ,Read More do not, would not send their children to public school but rather private school, religious or secular, sit on a public school board of education. They are there for one reason only ;to keep taxes as low as possible because those that elect them carry private school tuition. That is NOT an acceptable reason to direct/control/guide the education of public school students. Any position put forward that disputes this as the basis for parents of private school students being on a BOE is a lie.
Tova Markowitz May 17, 2013 at 05:18 pm
I'm amazed and shocked to hear about the shenanigans. Thank you for revealing what has been goingRead More on. I will forward your article to my friends and make sure we vote for Nachum. Thank you and your family for your dedication and efforts. Stay strong. We need you ,,
Chris Albanese May 17, 2013 at 04:05 pm
It's not just the teachers... As a parent of 2 going on 3 school aged children, I'm amazed at howRead More much our free public schools cost. We get a supply list every year of things like crayons and pencils which I get, although I don't see why it HAS to be crayola. The red crayon in the box from the 99 cents store is just as red as the one in the $4 box from someplace else. Also, I don't understand why I need to send in 4 boxes of tissues, paper towels, wipes, etc per child. When I was a kid, I remember keeping a little pack of kleenex in my desk for when I needed it. I'm sure the district can buy in bulk at half the cost to us and store it in the schools until needed. Also, as far as the teachers go, I'm not sure if they do it on LI, but when I was a SBM in the NYC DOE, we had what was called Teacher's Choice which was a check for $250 that every teacher would get on March 15 (?) to help pay for the classroom supplies they bought throughout the year. It always amazed me how many of the "supplies" were purchased on 03/14. I had the pleasure of denying some of the more bogus expenses. Also, anything they would spend above and beyond their reimbursement is now tax deductible I believe. My wife, sister, cousin and many friends were and some still are classroom teachers. I know firsthand how the good ones give much more than they get in their check(s). The trick is to weed out the ones that are only in it for the money, benefits and summers off and not the kids.
lilly May 14, 2013 at 02:18 pm
I do not understand how we never have a year with NO TAX INCREASES!!!!! It is pretty sad- we have toRead More get new resources, get more project bids and simply learn to say no or tighten up and not spend and what about salary freezes! We are all living with these types of challenges. We are living through difficult times. When I look around the town and see so many homes and stores for rent and sale- it should be a lightbulb moment. We can't continue to live this way. People will keep leaving the neighborhood and that's really not good for any of us!
Luncheon at Mother Kelly's
paul May 11, 2013 at 11:25 pm
Way to go Harvey! Happy Birthday and keep up the good work... Others depend on you....
Donna Galinsky April 25, 2013 at 09:07 pm
It is possible to find a rental, though it might not be easy. Many rentals are in co-op buildings.Read More They are typically not flexible and it is unlikely that you will be able to get into one of those. Your best bet would be in a multi-family house, There you are dealing with a homeowner, rather than a co-op board and a management company, who might be willing to listen to your plight. If you find a sympathetic homeowner you will be OK. It might take patience, but you should find someplace.